User:Crossfirexiv/Judgement

Winners:

Warrior

 * Elite: Gladiator's Cunning (User:Lann)
 * Non Elite: None

Ranger

 * Elite: None
 * Non Elite:  Penetrating Arrows (User:Lann)

Elementalist

 * Elite: Blizzard (User:Relyk)
 * Non Elite: None

Monk

 * Elite: Protector's Boon (User Canderouss)
 * Non Elite: Play Dead (Frvwfr2)

Necormancer

 * Elite: Minion Bond (User: Canderouss)
 * Non Elite: Animate Agonizing Horror (User: Rickyantoff)

Mesmer

 * Elite: Extra Effort (User: Frvwfr2)
 * Non Elite: Energy Transference (User Canderouss)

Assassin

 * Elite: Golden Mantis Stab (User: Seb2net)
 * Non Elite: Adapting Lunge (User:Єяøהħ)

Ritualist

 * Elite:
 * Non Elite:

Dervish

 * Elite:
 * Non Elite:

Paragon

 * Elite:
 * Non Elite:

JUDGEMENT
 * WARRIOR:

*	This is my world: Your Hope Ends Here: Blind Rage Signet of Intimidation
 * 4= Realistic = Pretty realistic. Anet of/c could add it to the game
 * 3= Innovation = Hammer warriors can achieve what this skill offers too.
 * 4= Effectiveness = Fairly Effective. Adrenaline is high, therefore makes it harder to use.
 * 0= Creativity = Provides no picture and isn’t too different from other skills.
 * 4= Balance = Looks pretty balanced. Would be more balanced if it were a melee attack rather than just a skill
 * Overall: 3.0
 * 2= Realistic = Anet probably would not add that to the game, for it gives you too much for a small cost.
 * 4= Innovation = Looks very original, not many skills work like that
 * 3= Pretty effective, but Doesn’t provide too much
 * 4= Has a nice picture, modified from ViM. Also, pretty different from other skills
 * 2= Balance = If it were in Guildwars, Im sure it will be too imba.
 * Overall: 3.0
 * 0=Realistic = Yeah right
 * 4= Innovation = Pretty origonal
 * 0= Effectiveness = Chyeah right
 * 5= Creativity = Pic is nice tbh, and it is definitely different from other skills
 * 0= Balance = ROfL
 * Overall:1.8
 * 5= Realistic = Actually Real enough to be put in Guildwars
 * 4= Innovation = Pretty innovative, Not many skills perform like that
 * 4= Effectiveness = Pretty effective TBH. The fact that it’s a signet is pretty painful.  Adrenaline would have been better
 * 3= Creativity = The pic looks like a random pic tbh. The sunglasses are intimidating tho :D
 * 2= Balance = Nerfed Immediately TBH.
 * Overall:3.6

You Fail Spear of Archimourus Shield of Saint viktor Gladiator’s Cunning
 * 3= Realistic = Not real enough to be put in GW
 * 4= Innovation = Not bad, new idea
 * 1= Effectiveness = Not effective with 10 recharge and 10 adrenaline
 * 2= Creativity = Pic isn’t bad, the name also would never be used in Guildwars
 * 3= Balance = kinda balanced TBH
 * Overall: 2.6
 * 0= Realistic = Weapon Spell on a warrior
 * 2= Innovation = Its already a skill in GW
 * 3= Effectiveness = Armor Penetration does not stack with the strength attribute. Other than that its kinda ok
 * 0= Creativity = Not really
 * 1= Balance = Underpowered
 * Overall:1.2
 * 0= Realistic = Weapon Spell on a warrior
 * 2= Innovation = Its already a skill in GW
 * 5= Effectiveness = Of/c everyone wants to use the skill that absorbs 600 damage.
 * 0= Creativity = Not really
 * 0= Balance = WAYYY too overpowered
 * Overall: 1.4
 * 5= Realistic = Very Realistic, Anet could definitely add that in. Duration is too long imo.
 * 4= Innovation = It’s a warrior’s Dream
 * 5= Effectiveness = Of/c Combine with an IAS for a good effect
 * 4= Creativity = Pic is pretty good and This skill actually makes sense
 * 3= Balance = Kinda balanced, Recharge + duration is pretty Imba
 * Overall: 4.2